Advanced Listening Practice

Priced Out - Transcript

A radio host, a housing researcher, and a mortgage broker discuss why young Canadians are being priced out of the property market.

speaker icon

If the audio player above doesn't work, click here to download the audio file.


Dana: Welcome back. Today we're looking at something that affects just about every young Canadian trying to get a foothold in the housing market. With me are Marcus Tremblay, who researches housing policy at the university level, and Sophie Baird, a mortgage broker who works primarily with first-time buyers. Marcus, let's start broad. How did we get to where we are now?

Marcus: Well, it's tempting to point at one thing, foreign investment or interest rates or whatever the headline happens to be that week. But the reality is more layered than that. We've had decades of underbuilding relative to population growth. Municipal zoning has made it incredibly difficult to increase density in the neighbourhoods where people actually want to live. And then on top of that, housing became an investment vehicle. It stopped being primarily about shelter and became a way to build wealth, which changes the incentives for everyone involved, homeowners, developers, governments, everybody.

Dana: Sophie, does that match what you see working with buyers?

Sophie: Completely. I sit across the table from couples in their late twenties, early thirties, who've done everything we told them to do. They've saved, they've got stable incomes, they've kept their debt low. And the numbers still don't work. Five years ago, a household income of a hundred and twenty thousand would have gotten you into a decent condo in most major cities. Now it barely qualifies you, and even if it does, you're competing with fifteen other offers and the winning bid is almost always over asking.

Marcus: And that's the psychological toll that doesn't show up in the data. It's one thing to say prices are high. It's another to watch a couple do everything right for five years and still come up short. That erodes trust in the system in ways that are hard to measure but very real.

Dana: Marcus, when you say underbuilding, what does that actually look like? Give us some numbers.

Marcus: Sure. The federal government's own estimates suggest we'd need to build roughly three and a half million additional homes by 2030 to restore affordability to something approaching reasonable. We're currently building at about half that pace, and the gap widens every year because population growth hasn't slowed. And it's not just volume, it's the type of housing. We keep approving single-family developments on the edges of cities where land is cheaper, but what we actually need is mid-rise, multi-unit housing in established neighbourhoods, close to transit and employment centres. The political will to do that has been lacking because existing homeowners tend to resist densification. And those homeowners vote in municipal elections at much higher rates than renters do. So the politics reinforce the problem.

Sophie: And that's the part that frustrates me the most, honestly. The people who already own property have every incentive to keep supply low, because that's what protects their investment. I don't think most of them are doing it consciously. Nobody wakes up and says, "I want to make sure young people can't afford to live near me." But when a neighbourhood association fights a new apartment building because of parking concerns or building height or the character of the street, the effect is the same whether the motivation is sincere or not.

Dana: Sophie, I want to push you on something. You're a mortgage broker. You benefit when people buy homes. Isn't there a conflict there when you're also commenting on affordability?

Sophie: Fair question, and I appreciate you asking it directly. Yes, I make my living when transactions happen. But I also turn people away regularly because the math doesn't add up for them. Last month, I had a couple come in, good incomes, both working full time, and I had to tell them they weren't ready. Not because anything was wrong with them, but because the stress test on their mortgage would have left them with almost nothing at the end of each month. I'd rather tell someone to wait two more years than put them into a mortgage that's going to keep them awake at night. And frankly, the current situation is bad for my business too. Fewer people can qualify, which means fewer transactions overall.

Marcus: That's an important point. This isn't a situation where the market is functioning well for anyone except existing property owners and large-scale investors. Builders are struggling with permit timelines and construction costs. Renters are being squeezed because rental supply is just as constrained. And municipalities are dealing with infrastructure pressure from sprawl they actively encouraged twenty years ago. Had we started building density in the early 2000s, we'd be in a fundamentally different position right now.

Dana: What about interest rates? We saw rates climb quite sharply and then begin to ease. Has that made any meaningful difference for the people you work with?

Sophie: It's complicated. Lower rates make monthly payments more manageable, which in theory helps buyers. But what tends to happen is that lower rates also push prices up, because buyers can suddenly afford to bid more. So you end up roughly where you started, just with a bigger mortgage over a longer term. The people I've seen benefit most from rate drops are those who already owned and were able to refinance. First-time buyers haven't gained much ground at all.

Marcus: And there's a psychological dimension to this that doesn't get enough attention. When people see prices dip slightly or rates come down, they rush in thinking it's their window, which creates a surge in demand that pushes prices right back up. The market has a way of absorbing any relief almost immediately. Without a sustained increase in supply, monetary policy adjustments are essentially rearranging the chairs.

Dana: So what would actually work? If you could change one thing tomorrow, what would it be?

Sophie: Speed up the approvals process for multi-unit builds. I've seen projects that took four years from the proposal to the permit. Four years. By the time they break ground, the cost estimates are outdated and the need has doubled. We don't need a new program or a new fund. We need the existing system to move faster. And I'd add, we need to stop treating every new development as a battle to be fought at the community level. There has to be a point where the broader need outweighs a neighbour's concern about a shadow on their garden.

Marcus: I'd broadly agree with that, though I'd add that we need to rethink the tax treatment of investment properties. When someone's third or fourth home is taxed at the same rate as someone's only home, we're implicitly encouraging accumulation. A progressive property tax, where the rate increases with each additional property, would discourage speculation without punishing ordinary homeowners. It wouldn't be popular with the investment crowd, and I'm under no illusion that it would be easy to implement, but the current structure rewards behaviour that makes the problem worse.

Dana: Last question, and I want a candid answer from both of you. Is this going to get better in the next ten years?

Sophie: For some people, in some places, yes. I think smaller cities and mid-sized towns are going to see more opportunity as remote work continues to shift where people can live. We're already seeing younger buyers looking beyond the big centres. But if you're asking whether someone earning a median income will be able to buy a home in a major city ten years from now, I honestly don't know. I'd like to say yes, but the trend line doesn't support it.

Marcus: I'm cautiously pessimistic, if that's a thing. The awareness is there now in a way it wasn't a decade ago. Governments are talking about housing in every election cycle, which is a necessary first step. But the gap between talking and building is enormous, and every year we don't close it, the problem compounds. The next generation of buyers isn't going to wait patiently. Something will have to give, and I'd rather it be policy than people's expectations of what a decent life in this country looks like.

Dana: Marcus, Sophie, thank you both for being so candid. That's all we have time for today.

© 2001-2026 esl-lounge.com