CELPIP
CELPIP Listening Part 6: Viewpoints
Practice Test 2
Part 6. Instructions.
You will hear a talk given by ONE person where different viewpoints on a single issue are presented. In the real test, you hear the discussion only once.
After the discussion, you will hear six questions. Choose the best answer, (A), (B), (C), or (D).
Try to answer after one listen to simulate test conditions.
View Transcript
Thank you all for joining us. The topic this evening is one that has moved, in the space of about three years, from a fringe proposal to a serious policy conversation in town halls across the country. I am referring, of course, to the four-day work week, and specifically to its adoption, in trial form, by a small but growing number of Canadian municipalities. Zorra Township in southwestern Ontario was among the first to attempt it. Others have since followed, with varying degrees of commitment and varying results. What I want to do tonight is walk you through the main lines of argument that have emerged from these experiments.
The most enthusiastic case for the shorter week has been made by Dr. Renata Olsson, a labour economist at the University of Guelph. Olsson's research draws on data from the Zorra trial and from comparable experiments in Iceland and the United Kingdom. Her central claim is that compressing the work week into four days, without reducing pay, produces measurable gains in productivity, sharp declines in absenteeism, and significant improvements in employee retention. Olsson argues that the conventional five-day model is a holdover from an earlier industrial era and bears little relation to the way knowledge work is actually performed. For her, the question is not whether the four-day week works, but how quickly other employers will recognize that it does.
A rather different view comes from Brendan MacIntyre, who served as the human resources director in a mid-sized Maritime municipality during its own twelve-month trial. MacIntyre is not opposed to the idea in principle. He acknowledges that staff reported higher morale and that turnover dropped during the trial period. However, he cautions against drawing sweeping conclusions from short-term pilots. According to MacIntyre, the productivity gains observed in the early months tended to fade as the novelty wore off, and some departments, particularly those involving public-facing services, struggled to maintain coverage. His position is that the four-day week may suit certain roles but should not be imposed uniformly across an entire workforce.
The most sceptical voice in this debate has come from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, which represents small employers across the country. The Federation does not dispute the academic findings outright, but it argues that what works for a salaried municipal workforce does not necessarily translate to the small businesses that depend on those municipalities for contracts and trade. Their concern is that as public sector employers adopt the shorter week, private sector employers will face mounting pressure to follow suit, often without the financial cushion to do so safely. The Federation has called for caution, more rigorous evaluation, and a clearer distinction between sectors before any broader rollout is considered.
Where does this leave us? My own reading is that Olsson's data is genuinely persuasive, but MacIntyre's warning about uniformity deserves more weight than it has received. The Federation's anxieties, meanwhile, point to something that proponents have been slow to address: that workplace reforms in the public sector inevitably reshape expectations in the private sector, whether or not the underlying economics support it. A more cautious, sector-by-sector approach, rather than a single national conversation, may ultimately serve us better than the current framing, which tends to cast the four-day week as either a clear breakthrough or a costly indulgence.
